Shocks for 5-6 inch lift (rear)

Stock shocks:
Shock Compressed Length : 13.875"
Shock Extended Length : 21.5"
Shock Travel Length : 7.625"

First shocks you listed:
*Collapsed Length (IN): 18.17
*Extended Length (IN): 29.92

Second:
Extended Length (in): 27.360 in.
Collapsed Length (in): 16.950 in.

With a 5" lift you could really go with either, they both have the same amount of travel but the first one you listed (the 24-186636) would give you a tad more room to work with. Not sure how either would ride, but I know you had bilsteins before.
 
Here's what the mcgaughys look like now
mate5y9u.jpg


Sent from my SM-N900V using Tapatalk