i may be a bit biased here, but you absolutely can't go wrong with discount tire. we can match any price but when looking online you need to factor in shipping which they don't show you until you get to check out and bend you over with it. we also offer tons of free services with out tires, and of course the free replacement road hazard warranty your not going to find anywhere else.
Although i am unfamiliar with any new york locations, there may not be one local to you. but its definitely worth it to take a look.